BL Info 7

More about Ball Lightning.

'Fireball at Salagnac' engraving from W. deFonvielle, Thunder and Lightning, 1868.

BALL LIGHTNING

The frequency of Ball Lightning events is not clearly known but it seems to be very infrequently. When it does occur it is usually associated with a thunderstorm but it can also occur, more rarely, in seemigly ordinary weather conditions as can ordinary lightning on rare occasions. There seems to be periods of inactivity and peak periods where many events take place, regionally and globaly.

The distinction between Ball Lightning and other forms of ALP (Anomalous Luminous Phenomena) such as 'Earthlights', 'Geophysical Meteors' and meteoric electrostatic / electromagnetic objects that leave no crater or material evidence is unclear. BL's are known to emanate from volcanic / earthquake activity, dust storms, thunderstorms and perhaps from astrophysical matter. It is suggested that thunderstorms moving over the earth have geophysical affects interacting with tectonic activity (Ol'khovatov et al.) and perhaps work together to produce Ball Lightning under certain conditions. At least one model (Leonov c1965) predicts an increased incidence of Ball Lightning during solar flares however some scientists say that there is no proof of this.

There are many theories about Ball Lightning. It may perhaps be that there is more than one explanation accounting for the wide variety and seemingly inconsistant behaviour. Variations in appearence and behaviour are such that all manner of hybrid types have been seen. The volatile red-yellow-orange type I photographed appears to be the most common although they are generally around soccer ball size. Striking 'up close encounters' of ones similar to the one I photographed can be found in BL Info 4 (see 'Glen Waverley 2001') and BL Info 5.

Volatile Ball Lightning has sometimes been referred to as 'Gorgons' ('Gorgons and Tornadoes' - E.Lewis) as is the BL associated with seismic activity in Japan. Super BL is another term sometimes used. One of the largest recorded was 100 metres diameter in Queensland, Australia. Similar exotic light phenomena was seen in Western Australia in the 1990's. Small scale (tennis to soccer ball size) BL can vary between highly 'charged' to faint transparent spheres or other shapes.

A more generic term 'Fireball' is also sometimes used but more often describes astronomical / geophysical meteors although it seems they too can exhibit similar electomagnetic or plasma characteristics.

Ball Lightning sounds range from being silent to hissing and crackling through to very loud roaring noises "as if standing next to a speeding train". The sounds can be in the Very Low Frequency range so that although some distance away, they can be heard and seen at the same time independent of 'the speed of sound'. See 'Abnormal sounds made by Fireballs - MIAC' and Ol'khovatov web sites. Most reports of Ball Lightning show that decay was silent, but in some reports the decay is described as explosive. Of one collection of 78 reports, 69% described silent decay and 31% explosive decay (Rayle 1966).

It is speculated that the unsolved mysterious explosion in Siberia (Tunguska) in 1908 could possibly have been a form of BL or 'Geophysical Meteor' rather than an ordinary meteorite. There was no crater found indicating it exploded above ground (see 'Geophysical Meteors' Ol'khovatov). In the same year as the Tunguska event severe dust storms were experienced in Australia and Halleys Comet also swept by Earth.

Previously in 1902, simultaneous dust, smoke and mud storms occurred globally. The scale and enormity of the dust ans smoke could not be accounted for when the amount of matter produced from the known volcanic activity of that year was examined. Ball Lightning/dust storms occurred at that time in Australia. Larger singular 'fireballs' were also observed travelling long distances while others rained down like bombs on the day of 12th November 1902.

Ball Lightning and Earthlights have been associated with earthquakes and are being studied (see TUVPO web site). BL has been directly observed and photographed emanating from volcanoes. Off the coast of Japan they rise in the air from volcanic vents beneath the sea and have terrorised coastal towns. Some Japanese have thought of them as the spirits of samurai warriors. Perhaps the myths of 'fire breathing dragons' diving from the sky originate from observed BL events.

They are mostly orange, yellow, red, gold or white but can also be blue, green, or purple (NASA survey). A bright central core is sometimes observed or they can be dim luminous transparent balls. Close observations of bright orange ones are often described as 'like looking at a minature sun' with rapid swirling or tornadic like inner structure, Internal 'lightning' is often seen. Sometimes lightning like bolts (or prolonged arcing) have been seen rising to the cloud base above or to the ground or even between multiple balls. The 'outer surface' of some balls have been described as having an intricate 'lattice like' lightning structure. Others have an indiscernable diffuse outline. There are also some rare accounts of BL appearing dark blue or greyish to black, sometimes with small crackling arcing.

BL are sometimes seen passing through glass windows. They can either leave a large diameter hole in the glass or no apparent hole at all. It has been theorised that BL can vapourise the glass in a small conical channel micro-millimeters in size. The surrounding glowing 'corona' reappears on the other side giving the illusion that a larger ball had passed through the window leaving the glass intact.

Earth Lights and Earthquake Lights may be related to Ball Lightning. Similar to Ball Lightning, Earth Lights can hover, fly rapidly, perform aerobatic manoeuvres, merge together and follow terrain or even chase cars giving the impression that they have intelligence or are controlled however geomagnetic / electromagnetic influences are possibly the cause of this behaviour. Ball Lightning is often attracted to railway lines giving a possible explanations to certain 'Ghost Train' legends.One example of this occurred near Diggers Rest, Melbourne (see BL Info 5).

Ern Mainka

An early illustration of an account of Ball Lightning showing three BL's. The origin of this image is unknown to me but is possibly also from the book 'Thunder and Lightning' 1868.

Two accounts of major Ball Lightning storms with multiple objects observed.

1956 - Keith H. Hill. At sea in the Great Australian Bight.


"...We were between Coffin Bay Peninsula and Flinders Island, travelling N.W. with a hard Northerly of half gale strength coming off the land some 25 miles away, with a rotten steep 4-5 metre wave giving us a belting. The cloud height was seemingly 1000 feet above us, a solid dark grey rippled even mass from horizon to horizon, as the sun was setting.

... Right after sunset, the electrical storm began, with large balls of lightning coming from the cloud base, dropping to the sea in 2 to 3 seconds of activity. These rather large balls seemed to be about one metre diameter occurring every 3 to 10 seconds, to within 100 metres (but fortunately not on our vessel!) to some miles away. The display allowed us to dispense with our compass sighting as so many times the sky was alight. We could see even thirty miles ahead to Flinders island and reefs surrounding with ease. The balls of lightning were of a sodium yellow colour internally with a bright active lilac blue surface of electrical energy.

.... The display continued for over two hours, so we saw at least 1,000 individual displays. Our eyes were effected to some degree, as the black night that followed seemed the blackest we had known and special care was taken in navigation until dawn arrived, with two on watch."

D.J.Turner, Journal of Meteorology Vol.21, No.214, December 1996. - expanded extract

c1963 - Paul Boyle. Massive Fireball storm in Ireland.

This account was written and forwarded by Paul Boyle 4/5/02 ( Now resident in Melbourne. Pers.com.)

"This is my account of my own experience which occured one Saturday when I was about thirteen in Derryash about 8 miles from Lurgan, county, Armagh, Ireland. On this day I was helping my two friends and their father to repair a damaged pump in the back paddock when suddenly we were confronted by the worst thunderstorm I've seen in my life (incidently I am now 52).

The storm became increasingly severe with heavy rain. So we began running to the house which was very difficult in wet clothes and soggy ground. The lightning was flashing every few seconds and the these orangy / red balls of fire started falling around us making strange sounds as they hurtled down leaving smoking black craters in the ground where they fell. These fireballs varied in size from a tennisball to a bowlingball and set everything on fire that they hit, like the trees in the orchard which were left blackened and severely damaged.

Soon however we were inside the house watching them 'dancing' up and down the road every time the lightning struck. When the storm finally abated I went home on my bike and my father explained that what we saw was ball lightning. Next week at school the teachers were so curious about our strange experience they made us write an essay of the event and paint pictures of it because it is so rare and some people do not believe that it exists."

" Every time their was a lightning strike these balls came down in dozens. There must have been hundreds that fell ", PB.


Recommended reading:

'Ball Lightning : An Unsolved Problem in Atmospheric Physics'. By Mark Stenhoff

Kluwer Academic / Plenum Publishers, New York. 1999. ISBN 0-306-46150-1


NASA Survey on Ball Lightning - 1966.

From 112 observers found following a questionaire sent to 4400 NASA employees at the NASA Lewis Research Centre April 1963

Download PDF File from National Institute for Discovery Science (NIDS) here :

http://www.nidsci.org/pdf/ball-lightning.pdf - 28kb

Example from the survey: During its lifetime, did the ball pass through small apertures, screens, or solid objects?

24 - yes,77 - no,11 - not answered.


An excerpt from Barry Greenwood's Ball Lightning Bibliography.

"......Ball Lightning has the potential for being easily mistaken for other, more anomalous objects. Ball Lightning is a poorly understood, probably natural phenomena that may account for some eyewitness reports of the sighting of a UFO. Witnesses to Ball Lightning have described round, glowing objects moving about at fast and slow speeds. These objects seem to interact with their environment - i.e. they turn corners, avoid obstacles, move along the contours of hilltops, etc. It is easy to imagine eyewitnesses who are unfamiliar with Ball Lightning research to interpret such events as due to ghosts or extraterrestrials and report their sightings this way. Using this listing, investigators can retrieve publications on Ball Lightning and, using the documents themselves, perhaps determine whether this phenomena is responsible for some reported sightings".

Link: http://www.project1947.com/shg/bl_intro.html


© 2002 - 2006 Ern Mainka